The Arrogance drinking game is a perfect mix of confidence, luck, and reckless decision-making. It’s a game where players must decide how bold they are willing to be, knowing that one wrong move could lead to drinking a massive concoction of mixed alcohol. Popular at house parties, college gatherings, and stag nights, Arrogance tests how far you can push your luck before it pushes back.
Table of Contents
What is the Arrogance Drinking Game?
Arrogance is a simple yet thrilling coin drinking game where players must wager how much alcohol to pour into a communal glass before flipping a coin. If they guess correctly, they escape unscathed. If they guess wrong, they must drink the entire contents of the glass—no matter how full it is.
Why It’s Called “Arrogance”
Because the more confident you get, the more you pour. And the more you pour, the more painful it is when you’re wrong. The game rewards modesty and punishes bravado — unless you’re lucky, in which case, ride that high until it crashes.
How to Play Arrogance – Step-by-Step Rules
Setting Up the Game
- A clear glass or party cup (preferably something transparent so the horror can build visually)
- Your drink of choice — beer is recommended (for obvious stomach-related reasons)
- Deck of cards (optional, for rule variations)
- A table or flat surface
- 3 or more players — though 4–8 is the sweet spot for ultimate chaos
Playing a Turn
- The first player pours as much of their drink as they want into the central glass.
- They then call “heads” or “tails” and flip a coin.
- If they guess correctly, they pass the turn to the next player without drinking.
- If they guess incorrectly, they must drink the entire contents of the central glass.
- The next player repeats the process, and the game continues.
Winning and Losing
There is no set “winner” in Arrogance—it’s all about survival. The game typically ends when players are either too drunk to continue or when they collectively decide to stop.
Fun Variations of the Arrogance Drinking Game
Arrogance is already a game of luck and boldness, but why stop at just flipping a coin? Here are some wild, hilarious, and extra-chaotic variations of the Arrogance Drinking Game that will take your party to the next level. Try them if you dare!
1. Russian Roulette Arrogance
Instead of flipping a coin, players roll a six-sided die:
- If they roll a 1 or 2, they drink the central glass.
- If they roll a 3 or 4, they are safe and pass the turn.
- If they roll a 5, they must add a shot of hard liquor to the glass.
- If they roll a 6, they choose someone else to drink it!
This Russian Roulette version keeps everyone on edge, and you never know when your luck will run out.
2. The Mystery Ingredient Challenge
Before the game starts, each player writes down a “mystery ingredient” on a piece of paper and puts it in a bowl. These ingredients can be anything from hot sauce, pickle juice, soy sauce, chocolate syrup, mashed-up chips, or even raw egg whites.
Every time a player loses, they must randomly pick a mystery ingredient and add it to the glass before drinking. If you think the regular Arrogance drink mix is bad, wait until you’re gulping down a beer-milk-hot sauce cocktail!
3. The “King of Arrogance” Mode
In this variation, one person is chosen as the King (or Queen) of Arrogance at the start of the game. Their job?
- To encourage others to pour more than they should.
- To mock and challenge players into being riskier.
- To change the rules on the fly (e.g., “Next round, losers have to take a shot before drinking the glass!”).
The King keeps their title until they themselves lose a round, at which point the person who last survived drinking the central glass becomes the new ruler.
4. Spin the Bottle of Doom
Before flipping the coin, the player must spin an empty bottle placed in the middle of the table. Whoever the bottle points to must add an extra shot to the communal glass, making every round more intense as the drink gets deadlier!
If the bottle points to the player who spun it, they must drink before flipping their coin, making their turn extra risky.
5. The Double Trouble Rule
If two people lose in a row, they must play Rock, Paper, Scissors immediately after drinking. The loser must take another shot or drink whatever is left in the central glass if someone else had already started pouring.
This adds a brutal twist that ensures no one is ever truly safe.
6. The “Call Your Shot” Version
Before flipping, the player must verbally declare how many rounds they’ll survive without losing. If they fail before reaching their goal, they must take one extra drink per round they missed.
For example:
- If someone says, “I’ll survive 5 rounds!” but loses on round 2, they must take 3 extra drinks.
- This creates insane moments where people go big or get wrecked trying to prove themselves.
Games Like Arrogance: More Party Favorites
If you love Arrogance, you’ll probably dig these other party classics:
- Kings Cup – another crowd-favorite with more structure and way more chaos.
- Ride the Bus – perfect for those who like a mix of memory and misery.
- Flip Cup – team-based and skill-focused.
- Waterfall – works great when the energy’s high and drinks are flowing.
These pair perfectly with Arrogance if you’re building out a full night of drinking games.
Best Drinks to Use for Arrogance
One of the biggest mistakes new players make in the Arrogance Drinking Game is choosing the wrong drink. Sure, the game is about taking risks, but picking the wrong beverage can turn an already chaotic experience into an absolute nightmare. Let’s break down the best and worst drink choices for Arrogance so you don’t end up regretting your life decisions.
The Best Drinks for Arrogance
✅ Beer (Light or Regular) – The safest and most popular choice. Beer is easy to drink, doesn’t hit too hard in small amounts, and won’t create a disgusting mix when combined with other players’ drinks. Stick to light or classic lagers if you want to last longer in the game.
✅ Cider – Another solid option for players who want something a little sweeter. It’s not too strong, and mixing different ciders together usually isn’t disastrous.
✅ Wine (White or Rosé) – If you’re feeling fancy, wine can work—but only in small amounts. Red wine is a disaster waiting to happen (see below). White and rosé wines mix better and don’t turn the central glass into a thick, heavy punishment drink.
✅ Pre-Mixed Cocktails – Drinks like vodka lemonade, rum and Coke, or gin and tonic can keep things fun without being overwhelming. Just make sure they aren’t too strong, or you’ll regret every sip.
The Worst Drinks to Use for Arrogance
🚫 Dark Liquors (Whiskey, Rum, Brandy, etc.) – Sure, you might think pouring a splash of whiskey makes you a legend, but wait until someone mixes it with beer and orange soda. These drinks are too strong for a casual party game and will make the central glass undrinkable way too quickly.
🚫 Tequila or Vodka Shots – These are fine for side-drinking, but adding them to the central glass? Absolute madness. The more tequila or vodka in the mix, the faster people will start dropping out or vomiting in the corner.
🚫 Red Wine – A huge mistake unless you enjoy drinking a heavy, acidic, stomach-wrecking sludge. Red wine and beer do not mix well, and it only takes one person to ruin the entire game by adding it.
🚫 Energy Drinks or Soda – Mixing energy drinks like Red Bull with beer and liquor? You’re asking for a one-way ticket to the worst hangover of your life. Sodas can also make the drink way too fizzy and harder to chug.
🚫 Milk, Juice, or Anything Dairy-Based – If someone suggests adding Baileys, eggnog, or a splash of milk, stop them immediately. These drinks will curdle when mixed with acidic alcohols, creating a chunky, undrinkable nightmare. Do you really want to drink alcoholic cottage cheese? Didn’t think so.
Ultimate Chaos Mode: What Happens When You Mix Everything?
If you’ve ever played Arrogance long enough, you know that at some point, someone gets reckless and pours whatever they have left in their cup into the central glass. This can result in truly cursed combinations like:
- Beer + Whiskey + Orange Juice = Carbonated regret.
- Red Wine + Vodka + Coke = The Devil’s Sangria.
- Tequila + Milk + Sprite = A horrific science experiment gone wrong.
At this point, it’s not even a drink—it’s a dare. If you’re playing in a group that lets the central glass become a monster of its own, just pray that you don’t lose the coin flip.
Pro Tips for Choosing the Right Drink
- Stick to lighter drinks if you want the game to last longer.
- Avoid strong liquors unless you want someone to pass out before the game is even halfway done.
- If you see someone pouring a mix of beer, wine, and dairy, consider quitting before it’s too late.
- If the central glass looks like a science experiment, play conservatively—losing will be brutal.
Arrogance is a game of luck, confidence, and a little bit of insanity. It’s a fantastic choice for large groups looking to break the ice and create unforgettable party moments. Whether you play it safe or go all in, one thing is certain—this game will keep everyone entertained.
Try it at your next party and see who’s truly the most arrogant among your friends. Just remember: what goes into the glass must eventually be drunk!